Just saw their early review on TV; overall they love the movie but are not impressed with the dialogue. Following points stood out from their review:
- Overall probably the best Star Wars since Empire.
- Dialogue is clunky, pedestrian. Dramatic moments lose some of the effect because of limited power of the dialogue.
- Though we know how the movie is going to end, the movie does well to keep the suspense going.
- Overall a good, fun movie in the tradition of the old space operas.
To put this in perspective, Ebert loved Phantom and was not impressed with Attack of the Clones and was a great admirer of the original trilogy.